
Tuesday November 11, 2020 Happy Veterans Day
Election Day -7
73 Days until the Inauguration on January 20, 2021
I’ve been curious about the Supreme Court case regarding The Affordable Care Act. I started reading about it in wikipedia. It’s interesting. The question isn’t whether millions of people are going to lose their health care. The questions are about who has the right to do what to whom, or not. It involves rights of the states, the federal government and the individual.
Before I looked into it I had heard legal commentators talking about the question – if one part of the law is wrong do you have to throw out the whole thing? There was a question of whether part can be separated from the whole or not (Kavanaugh’s question).
There was also talk about the penalty for not having the insurance going to zero. For some reason this was a big deal and it was Alito who made the point that if you say a part is integral to say the running of a bus and you take the part out and it still runs then it wasn’t integral. This is the point about the penalty. They took it out and the law didn’t fall apart.
Lastly, Roberts said that it was not their job to throw out the whole law, and he speculated that was what Congress wanted them to do because they weren’t able to do it. The “They” and “Them” being the Republicans in Congress. I mean they only tried like fifty times.
So that’s what I kind of understood going into my looking at the current arguments about this law before the Supreme Court. To make it an weirder case than usual, the Justice Department was arguing against the law. They are supposed to argue for current laws, not against them, but then again this is Barr and the Drumf administration.
The first thing I learned was that there were two laws: The ACA and The HCERA, which was the part that required most Americans to have health insurance by 2014.
The next thing was the term “certiorari” – “to make certain.” In 2011 The state of Florida (no doubt head up by that idiot Biondi) sued HHS wanting to know if the law was constitutional. One of the questions involved the term “individual mandate,” which is not a health insurance term but a legal term and can be applied to the ACA. An individual mandate is a requirement by the government that certain individuals purchase a good or service, like say health insurance.
The court ruled in 2011 (or 2014) that the health care individual mandate (ie making people buy health insurance) was not a proper use of the Commerce clause of the Constitution. The Commerce Clause of the Constitution says that the Federal Government has the right to regulate commerce between states and with other countries. RGB argued that it did fall under this clause because the companies offering insurance worked across state lines.
There was a part of the law that was called the Medicaid expansion and this was deemed unconstitutional to force a state to choose to expand because the choice was expand or lose funding, which was really no choice at all. Therefore it became optional.
One of the questions was whether forcing people to buy insurance was a tax, or they’re not buying it, a penalty. This has to do with the taxing power of the government. If it’s a tax and you don’t like it and want to fight it in court the law says you have to pay the tax and seek to get your money back via the courts. Not sure about penalties. Then there is the question of “direct tax” or not. A direct tax is a tax on an individual or property as opposed to one on a transaction, which is called indirect.
If the individual mandate is a tax then the government can collect the money even while a case against it is pending. If it’s a penalty then the plaintiff can get the courts to file an injunction and stop the government from collecting the money until the case is settled.
The court said for the purposes of constitutionality it was a tax, ie the government could collect the money. But it was not a direct tax. The Commerce Clause is used to regulate commerce. Here if an individual does nothing, ie doesn’t get insurance they are charged under the commerce clause. How can you be charged for not conducting commerce?
Ginsburg was having none of it. The uninsured, as a class, costs everyone money and hence is interstate commerce. Especially because people cross state lines to get health care. (I remember a guy who railed against something or other in Nevada but lived over the border in California because he got better health care.)
So now the current case is around the idea of “Severability.” Can part of the law be taken out and not effect the rest of the law? Republican lawyers were trying to say that if the individual mandate was not allowed then the whole law failed. This is where Alito came in and said that since the individual mandate charge has gone to zero and the law hasn’t failed then it’s hard to argue that point.
Kavanaugh said as much in addressing the severability as well.
It seems the ACA will withstand yet another challenge.
I can’t believe we have to treat some of these idiots as smart.
PS One of my favorite movie scenes where Woody Allen while waiting in line for a movie gets in an argument with a pompous community college professor over Marshall McLuhan’s work. Woody pulls McLuhan out from behind a sign board and McLuhan says to the prof, “You know nothing of my work.” Don’t we all wish for something like that at times?
Leave a Reply